SUGAR & SPICE
Gimme an S! (Sophomoric Sexual Silliness). Gimme a U! (Unsurpassably Uncouth Utterings from
Unsophisticated Underclassmen). Gimme a G! (Gratuitously Gauche Girl Gags). Gimme an A! (Amazing
Amounts of Anti-gay Acrimony). Gimme an R! (Relentlessly Rigorous Rah-Rah Routines). Gimme an S!
(Somewhat Satirical and Scathing Send-up of Saucy Schoolgirl Solidarity). Gimme a P! (Pathetically
Prurient Pregnancy-and-Period Puns). Gimme an I! (Insufferable Infusions of Ill-conceived Innuendo).
Gimme a C! (Cheerleaders Choose to Champion their Cherry-Cheeked Captain by Committing Crimes
Concealed in Clever Cute Costumes). Gimme an E! (Egregiously Exploitative yet Engaging Example of
Existing Expressions of Entertainment).
Directed by first-timer Francine McDougall, this bit of cotton candy goes where Porky’s,
Heathers, Ten Things I Hate About You, The Opposite of Sex, and But I’m a
Cheerleader have already gone before. When their captain (Marley Shelton) gets pregnant by the
star quarterback (James Marsden), the rest of the Lincoln High cheerleading team (Rachel Blanchard,
Mena Suvari, Sara Marsh, Melissa George) rob a bank to help out; narration is provided by a jealous
outsider (Marla Sokoloff) who’s become a police informer. Funny and cute, but the self-conscious
political incorrectness grates after a while . . . say, 10 minutes.
— Peg Aloi