*** Bill Charlap Trio
WRITTEN IN THE STARS
(Blue Note)
Pianist Charlap plays all standards — which on the face of it is a concession to the status quo.
But on the other — just listenýto this guy. He opens with some Bill Evans–impressionist
chords, a phrase of tumbling Monk whole tones followed by equally Monkish broken chords, then the
low-register opening of Cole Porter’s “In the Still of the Night” and then a high-end run into the
bridge. There’s variety like this in each of the CD’s 11 tracks, but it never sounds merely showy.
Charlap’s been credited with thinking like a singer, but no one would sing the lyrics to these songs
with his rubato attack. And yet every move he makes reinforces the overall melody and shape of the
song.
Maybe that’s because he never leaves the original melody far behind — it’s always there in his
recurring conversational paraphrases. Maybe it’s his voice leading — the harmonic underpinning
of those long arcs of song is so sure that he can leave a note hanging indefinitely without letting
the tensile strength of the composition go slack. And maybe it’s the way his trio mates — bassist
Peter Washington and his brother, drummer Kenny — stay with him. (Listen to the way Peter adds
another finger to Charlap’sÞleft hand in “Blue Skies.”) Or maybe it’s Charlap’s deathless lyricism
— the brooding urbanity of Harold Arlen and Ira Gershwin’s “The Man that Got Away,” the city
night-sky romanticism of the Arlen/Leo Robin title track.
— Jon Garelick
|