**1/2 Alien Ant Farm
ANTHOLOGY
(New Noize/DreamWorks)
New-metal vanity labels are all the rage these days. It hasn’t been even a year since Papa Roach
released their monster debut album and already the band are foisting their friends’ records upon an
unsuspecting public.
Alien Ant Farm, the first signing to Papa Roach’s New Noize label, used to share California club
dates with their benefactors, but they’re no carbon-copy P-Roach imitation. For one thing, AAF
singer/songwriter Dryden Mitchell isn’t as angry or tortured as head Roach Coby Dick — he does
write about his frustrations a lot, but his songs always have an upside. His pop instincts shine
through on the first single, “Movies,” an upbeat break-up song that sets the mood. The band
ultimately sound less influenced by metal than by classic alterna-rock, with nary a nod to hip-hop or
hardcore. The fussy rhythm section is the weak link, but Mitchell makes up for that with his cutting
vocals and personal approach to songwriting. On “Happy Death Day,” he shows flashes of sardonic wit
beneath the introspection (“Papa’s got a brand new body bag for you”). But Alien Ant Farm’s funniest
joke is their disco-metal cover of Michael Jackson’s “Smooth Criminal,” a relatively faithful version
featuring plenty of upper-register yelps from Mitchell.
— Sean Richardson