* Howard Zinn
STORIES HOLLYWOOD NEVER TELLS US
(AK Press/Alternative Tentacles)
Hollywood script pitching is an art form many clever and talented people have tried to
master, with varying degrees of success. But Howard Zinn’s new spoken-word CD has to be
the first time a self-described radical historian (best known for his controversial tome
A People’s History of the United States) has made the attempt. Although AK Press
Audio plugs itself as “the finest in audio agit-prop,” this highly informal 1999 lecture
might best be described as agit-flop. First, there’s a gratuitous introduction by
alterna-radio guru David Barsamian that clocks in at just under 10 minutes — a
considerable chunk of the 58-minute CD — while making a dunderheaded attempt to
connect Zinn’s work to Sufi philosophy. Yep. From there, Zinn embarks on a slow march
across real time in his roaming talk, lamely chastising Hollywood’s glorification of
war and its failure to treat episodes like Shays’s Rebellion, the Spanish-American
War, and the civil-rights movement from the dissident perspective of average working
people and minorities. The gist of Zinn’s quixotic oration is that we don’t — but we
should — see films about such little-known events as the Lawrence textile strike and
radicals like Eugene Debs, Mother Jones, and Helen Keller. True enough, but hearing
Zinn casually express his desire to see more social-realist drama on the big screen
is, in a word, underwhelming.
— Damon Smith
|