Melancholy chorus Tree By Leaf are Of the Black and Blue BY SAM PFEIFLE
	Of the Black and Blue By Tree by Leaf | www.treebyleaf.org

My brush with our reality-television culture came earlier this year, judging a songwriting competition for NEMO (a SXSW wannabe you may or may not have noticed happening in October), which owns the Boston Music Awards, one of which Ray LaMontagne won despite the fact that he’s played roughly five gigs in Boston in his life. Beforehand, in the crowded Starbucks where the songwriting competition was being held, I mostly chatted with the competitors about how it was kind of like American Idol and how we were all basically embarrassed to be involved, but the Phoenix was a sponsor and the winner would take home a Les Paul guitar and move on to compete further in Boston for a chance to go to Hawaii. Who doesn’t want to go to Hawaii on someone else’s dime?

The thing started, and Jason Spooner, Emilia Dahlin, Rachel Griffin, and Pete Kilpatrick proceeded to one-up each other with a series of pretty damn impressive performances considering they had three "judges" sitting in front of them (a colleague of mine from WFNX and a NEMO rep were the other two) and they were playing in friggin’ Starbucks (which was fine, actually, but still). Then Garrett Soucy came on the stage. What did he do differently? It’s hard to say. Armed like three of the others with just an acoustic guitar, he didn’t play like a singer-songwriter. He kind of jabbed at it like an indie rocker, imagining a drummer and bassist to fill in the pauses and quietudes. He didn’t mind letting it hang in the air. And his songs had choruses, but they were progressive, and their narratives covered serious ground (and time — he was relating a relationship first to Roman times, then the Middle Ages, then the Renaissance, etc., I’m pretty sure).

Soucy might never be the folk-circuit star that Jason Spooner could eventually be, nor the pop star Kilpatrick could be with his charming-the-pants-off-all-women charisma. He won’t be the next Diana Krall, which is a real possibility for cutey-pie Griffin, nor an independent self-made star of the college circuit, as is likely for Dahlin. He’s a special talent, though. Sufjan Stevens special; Elliot Smith special. And if half of you never heard of Stevens, and only heard of Smith because he killed himself, that’ll tell you something about being a special talent. It doesn’t always translate into worldwide acclaim. Like many who seem to live inside their work, Soucy’s sure not much for self-promotion. He defines "aw shucks." Maybe that’s why it’s December, and I’m just getting around to reviewing the latest release by his band, Tree by Leaf, which came out in May. I’m not sure what other explanation there could be. Of the Black and Blue is spectacular, the type of album that demands that you spend time with it and nothing else. The type of album that is all-consuming in and of itself — not background music, not what you put on at a party, not something you would hear on the radio, because one song just wouldn’t be enough, and they wouldn’t pick the right one anyway.

For his annual GFAC compilation, Charlie Gaylord picked Tree by Leaf’s "Never Seems to Leave," which sure has a certain David Lynchian shuffle to it — one of those songs that’s fast despite the fact that it’s played slowly (or maybe it’s the other way around). Plus, it opens almost perfectly for a Maine compilation: "Trailer park, you’re aglow / You’re a dusted nineteen-sixty-four volume." Yes, it’s that weird mix of backwoods and frontline intellectualism that Maine seems to revel in. It’s hard to beat, too, Garret’s interplay with wife Sirii, who comes in for the next verse and an ensuing chorus where she sings what’s picked out on the bass so nicely you almost don’t notice, then breathes out the barest backing to Garret’s second verse. Man, it’s good on the headphones. Every once in a while, their voices don’t quite hold up, but it totally works in a Brechtian sense of making you notice the construction of the music itself — this is the way you do this sort of thing, whether you’ve got classically trained voices doing or not it is really irrelevant.

But that’s maybe the fourth best song on the disc. "Rupert Sheldrake’s Favorite Girl" got 15, maybe 20 listens. I love this song in a big way, with Garret’s vocals doubled throughout — really two tracks, not just a chorus pedal or an echo, and they’re just the slightest bit off, both in good ways, with the right channel just the slightest behind, adding an urgency and pushing everything forward. There’s a great guitar break after the first verse, followed by a stellar chorus: "Wait a minute / Hold the phone / I still gotta walk this memory home / I’m in love with Rupert Sheldrake’s favorite girl." Who’s Sheldrake? God, I hope it’s nobody. Right after the chorus, a really deep organ comes in, sounding like loud stadium applause, very country-rock, as though the Jayhawks decided that instead of rosy-cheeked harmonies they wanted to go the ironic route: "‘That’s funny,’ I said ‘because it’s not about you’ / The sky grew dark, and the wind did blew / ‘That’s weird,’ she said, and handed me a cigarette off the dash."

At the very end, you can hear the slightest chair creek when Soucy sits back up after letting out the final note. Like much of the rest of the record, you feel you’re privy to something remarkably intimate, created just for you and this time and place.

Sam Pfeifle can be reached at sam@phx.com